It’s the Most Wonderful Bubble of All

A Festive History of Financial Follies

A Tale of Bubbles: From Tulips to Crypto

As the Christmas season approaches, the air is filled with the familiar tunes of “It’s the Most Wonderful Time of the Year.” But amidst the festive cheer, a different kind of excitement is brewing in the financial markets. A new speculative frenzy has gripped investors, turning cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin into the most speculative frenzy in human history.

History, however, offers a sobering perspective. From the tulip fields of 17th-century Holland to the housing bubble of the late 20th century, humanity has a penchant for speculative bubbles. These episodes of irrational exuberance, often fueled by greed and fear of missing out, have led to periods of rapid asset price inflation followed by dramatic collapses.

As we review the history of financial bubbles, we’ll uncover the common threads that connect past excesses to today’s crypto craze. By examining the tulip mania, the South Sea Bubble, the tech bubble 1.0, and the housing bubble, we can gain valuable insights into the psychology of speculative behavior and the potential risks associated with investing in assets without intrinsic value.

These past bubbles, once the darlings of their time, have since turned into cautionary tales, their stories whispered in hushed tones as if they were scary ghost stories and tales of the glories long long ago. They serve as reminders of the dangers of unchecked speculation and the fragility of human nature. As we navigate the turbulent waters of the crypto market, it's essential to heed the lessons of history and approach with a healthy dose of skepticism.

Tulipmania: The First Mistletoeing

In the 1630s, the Dutch Republic was the wealthiest and most sophisticated economy in Europe during the peak of the renaissance, but even rational traders couldn’t resist the allure of tulips. That’s when the first recorded speculative bubble happened. These exotic flowers, with their striking colors and patterns, became a symbol of status. Initially, tulips were sold as physical bulbs, but their rarity and slow cultivation process (it could take years for a bulb to mature and bloom) created a unique market dynamic. To meet surging demand, traders began selling futures contracts, agreements to buy bulbs at a later date for a set price. This allowed buyers and sellers to speculate on higher price in the future without the actual bulbs exchanging hands. Speculation was rampant. Contracts for tulip bulbs traded hands multiple times before the bulbs were even planted.

Prices Reach Absurd Levels

At the peak of the mania in 1636-1637, tulip contracts became so valuable that a single rare bulb, or the contract for one, could be worth the price of an Amsterdam canal house—then one of the most coveted pieces of real estate in the world. To put this in perspective, a canal house in 17th-century Amsterdam could cost around 10,000 guilders, the equivalent of several years’ wages for a skilled artisan.

Ordinary people, including craftsmen and farmers, entered the market hoping to profit from the boom. Some sold property, took loans, or pooled money with others to speculate on tulips, believing prices would keep rising indefinitely.

The Bubble Bursts

The speculative market relied on a constant influx of new buyers willing to pay higher prices, but in February 1637, confidence wavered. During an auction at the peak, a few lots failed to sell, triggering panic. Buyers began to realize that prices were unsustainable, and the market collapsed almost overnight.

Contracts became worthless as buyers vanished, and those who had taken on debt to speculate were left ruined. The first bubble to become a scary ghost story.

The South Sea Bubble: Be a Good Cheer

Britain was gripped by excitement over the South Sea Company, which promised untold riches through exclusive trade with South America. Shares soared from £100 to £1,000 in just months, buoyed by a frenzy of speculative buying and government backing.

The South Sea Bubble, was fueled by a perfect storm of factors, including social contagion and influential endorsements. As more and more investors piled into the company singing like Andy Williams “The most wonderful company”, a herd mentality took hold, with individuals feeling pressured to participate to avoid missing out on potential gains. Politicians, businessmen, and even Isaac Newton himself had to get in (at the top), promoting the company and downplaying its risks.

The bubble eventually burst in September 1720, when investors realized the company's true value and began selling their shares en masse. This triggered a panic, as everyone rushed to sell their overvalued stock. The price plummeted, wiping out the wealth of countless investors (including Newton) and causing widespread economic hardship.

The South Sea Bubble serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of speculative excess and the importance of sound financial practices. It highlights the risks of investing in companies based on hype and promises rather than solid fundamentals. The legacy of the South Sea Bubble continues to shape financial regulations and investor behavior to this day

The Beanie Baby Bubble: The Kids Jingle Beaning

The 1990s witnessed a peculiar phenomenon that captivated the nation: the Beanie Baby craze. It was the most wonderful time of the year for speculators, as these seemingly ordinary stuffed animals became objects of desire and speculation. Ty Warner, the puppet master behind this plush pandemic, skillfully stoked the flames of demand by limiting production and retiring specific designs. This scarcity, coupled with clever marketing, sent speculators into a frenzy, their hearts racing faster than a kid on Christmas morning.

The rise of the internet, particularly eBay, further fueled the bubble. The online marketplace became a digital playground for speculators, where they could buy and sell Beanie Babies at exorbitant prices. Speculators, driven by greed, snapped up beanies at retail prices and listed them at significantly higher prices on eBay, hoping to profit off peoples stupidity. Speculators would go to the Beanie Baby handbook and try and sell them for ten year future value. Something that was originally $5 could be sold as much as $2,500 or the ten year estimated value!

(as shown in the image below)

The fervor reached its peak when certain Beanie Babies, particularly limited edition and retired models, fetched astronomical prices. One of the most sought-after was Princess Diana the Bear, which sold for a staggering $70,000 at auction. This extraordinary price tag showcased the extent of the speculative bubble and the irrational exuberance that surrounded Beanie Babies.

However, as with all bubbles, the Beanie Baby craze was destined to burst. As the market became saturated with these toys, demand began to wane. The once-coveted Beanie Babies lost their luster, and their prices plummeted, almost over night. The dream of easy money turned into a nightmare, a scary ghost story of the past. The Beanie Baby bubble serves as a reminder of the dangers of the greater fool theory.

Bitcoin: The Most Wonderful Bubble

The cryptocurrency world is singing its loudest carols yet, heralding Bitcoin’s meteoric rise to $104,028. Enthusiasts cheer on social media, and crypto memes are flooding the internet. But beneath this glittering facade lies a troubling truth: Bitcoin, like bubbles before it, is poised for an inevitable pop. Its soaring price echoes the crescendo of every speculative frenzy, from tulips in 17th-century Holland to the beanie babies of the 90s.