The Coastal Journal White Paper: Zero Day Options Expiration Bubble

Unveiling Today's Bubble by Unraveling the Original Frenzy of Tulip Mania

Introduction:

In this exclusive edition white paper from the Coastal Journal, prepare to embark on a captivating journey that seamlessly intertwines the historical echoes of the past with the pulsating rhythms of the present. We invite you to join us as we unravel the parallels between two distinct yet interconnected phenomena: the legendary Tulip Mania of the 17th century Dutch Republic and the modern day bubble of Zero Date Options Expirations (0DTE) in today's dynamic US stock market landscape.

As the seasons transition from winter's frost to spring's bloom, we find ourselves drawn to the timeless allure of history, where lessons from the past resonate with startling relevance in the modern world. The saga of Tulip Mania, with its feverish speculation and spectacular collapse, serves as a reminder of the enduring allure and inherent risks of speculative bubbles.

Against this backdrop, we turn our gaze to the present day, where financial innovation and technological advancements have birthed a new breed of speculative trading instruments—0DTE options. These derivatives, with their promise of rapid gains and adrenaline-fueled trading, stand as a testament to the enduring allure of market euphoria. Yet, as history has shown time and again, the ascent of bubbles is matched only by their spectacular crash. The allure of quick riches gives way to the sobering reality of financial ruin, leaving behind a trail of shattered dreams and broken fortunes.

Methodology:

Drawing upon historical accounts, empirical data, and economic principles, this research employs a multi-level approach to analyze Tulip Mania and today’s 0DTE options Mania. By examining the socioeconomic context, market dynamics, and market mechanics, this white paper seeks to provide a comprehensive understanding of speculative bubbles and their implications for investors and market stability.

Tulip Mania, A Historical Prelude to Speculative Bubbles:

Tulip Mania, which started in the Dutch Republic in the 17th century, remains a powerful example of irrational speculation and market excess. It started with the rise of the Dutch Golden Age. As Amsterdam emerged as a hub of international trade and finance, the demand for tulip bulbs, imported from Turkey, surged among the Dutch elite, leading to a speculative frenzy.

The Bubble Blossoms:

The speculative fervor surrounding tulip bulbs was fueled by a combination of factors, including social status, scarcity, and financial innovation. Initially confined to horticulturalists and collectors, tulip trading evolved into a speculative market, facilitated by the Amsterdam Stock Exchange and the development of futures contracts. As prices soared to new heights, fueled by leverage and positive feedback loops, tulip bulbs became symbols of wealth and extravagance. At the peak of the bubble, tulip bulbs were selling for nine times the average Dutchman’s wages. This meant that the average Dutchman would have to work for nine years straight and survive without food or water to be able to buy a single tulip bulb! The reality was as absurd as it sounds today.

The Birth of Options Contracts:

The emergence of futures contracts in the tulip market laid the groundwork for the development of options contracts, enabling traders to speculate on future price movements without owning the underlying asset. Futures contracts provided a mechanism to speculate on higher prices in the future, while options contracts introduced new dimensions of leverage and speculation. Standardization of contract terms and the proliferation of trading venues further fueled the speculative frenzy as Amsterdam created the first official stock market, which led to unsustainable price levels for the pretty flower. These agreements enabled them to lock in current prices, shielding themselves from potential spikes in the future. Consequently, these forward contracts gained immense value, serving as a strategic tool for participants to navigate the volatile tulip market with confidence.

Speculation:

As the tulip trade expanded and prices surged, speculators entered the market, seeking to profit from price movements without intending to take physical delivery or own actual tulip bulbs. Futures contracts provided a vehicle for speculation, allowing traders to leverage their capital and magnify potential gains (or losses).

Understanding this aspect of the tulip mania is crucial, as it sheds light on the fundamental dynamics that drove the initial bubble and draws striking parallels to the current AI-fueled frenzy 0DTE in today's markets. Because these forward option contracts served as a mechanism for participants to secure the underlying asset at current prices, they were shielded from potential future price hikes. However, as demand for these contracts surged, driven by a desire to avoid paying inflated prices later on on tulips, their value soared.

This escalating demand, fueled by the fear of missing out on lucrative profits, led to a speculative frenzy in which individuals bought these contracts without any intention of owning the actual tulips. Instead, they aimed to capitalize on the rising prices of the contracts themselves, perpetuating a cycle of speculation and driving prices ever higher. This phenomenon persisted from 1634 to 1637, during which the allure of quick profits overshadowed any interest in actual tulip ownership, underscoring the powerful influence of speculation on market dynamics. At the height of the bubble, a tulip bulb sold for an absurdly high price of 5,200 guilders, equal to the value of a mansion on the Amsterdam Grand Canal at that time.

When the Bubble Burst:

The dramatic collapse of Tulip Mania in February 1637 signaled the abrupt end to a period characterized by speculative excess and economic irrationality. The sheer magnitude of the frenzy is staggering, evidenced by the astonishing twentyfold increase in tulip prices at the peak of the mania. This feverish speculation reached its zenith in January and February of 1637, drawing in a wave of new participants, many of whom staked their savings or even mortgaged their possessions to join the bulb trade.

The pinnacle of speculative fervor culminated in an unprecedented auction on February 5, 1637, when bids soared to an astronomical 90,000 guilders—a sum that dwarfed the wealth amassed by even the wealthiest merchants of the era. However, as February progressed, cracks began to appear in the facade of the tulip market. Isolated instances of florists selling off their holdings without reinvesting triggered a domino effect, with panic spreading rapidly among investors.

The catalyst for the collapse came at an auction in Haarlem, where the absence of any bids for tulip bulbs sent shockwaves through the market. The subsequent downward spiral in prices, coupled with a sudden evaporation of liquidity, left investors reeling and precipitated a cascade of "fire sales" by leveraged speculators desperate to unload their holdings. In a matter of weeks, the once-thriving market for tulip bulbs evaporated, leaving in its wake a trail of financial ruin and dealing a severe blow to the Dutch economy.

Zero Day Options Expiration (0DTE):

Fast forward to the present day, and the US stock market finds itself blowing one of the biggest bubbles in history, fueled by innovative financial instruments like 0DTE options. These short-term derivatives, a darling of retail investors hungry for quick profits and adrenaline-fueled trading, have surged in popularity since their inception in 2022.

Similar to the fevered hysteria of Tulip Mania centuries ago, the allure of leverage, speculation, and lightning-fast price movements has cast a spell over market participants. But beneath the euphoria lies a dark undercurrent of uncertainty—a nagging suspicion that the AI rise may be built on nothing more than a house of cards.

The emergence of 0DTE options in late 2022 marked a pivotal moment in the evolution of financial markets. Introduced by the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE), these instruments grant investors the tantalizing opportunity to buy or sell stocks at a predetermined price within the same trading day.

Early indicators in 2024 suggest that Nvidia, which has replaced Tesla as the number one company in options trading, is emerging as a dominant force in the AI options market, further fueling the fervor that has gripped speculators. But as history has shown time and again, the allure of bubbles is as seductive as it is treacherous.

Who introduced these financial innovations?

The CBOE has created derivatives since its inception in 1973. Beginning with traditional options that started out as quarterly, monthly, and weekly contracts, the CBOE has consistently pushed the boundaries of market derivatives.

What are 0DTE options?

Simply put, they are derivative contracts designed to speculate on short-term price movements or flat-out bets on the stock price being higher or lower that day. Unlike traditional options with longer durations, 0DTE options expire at the end of the same trading day, offering investors, traders, or speculators a lightning-fast avenue for speculation.

The importance of knowing about options is key to understanding today’s US AI stock bubble. Historically, investors primarily held the underlying shares or stocks of a company while supplementing their portfolios with options contracts, often based on factors like anticipated earnings or economic trends. These options typically had longer durations, such as yearly, quarterly, or monthly contracts, providing investors ample time to assess market conditions and make informed decisions.

The next part of the white paper is for paid subscribers. There is a lot more details to come, so if you would like to continue to learn about the 0DTE bubble, please subscribe and enjoy. (Thank you)